Who Is Donatella Versace's Topless, Sun-Scorched Doppelgänger? Maureen O'Connor · 01/28/10 12:31AM Paparazzi have mistaken this lady for Donatella at least four times. Rumor has it she's an "Italian countess who has had a home on St. Bart's for over ten years." An investigation into Fake Donatella, and telling the two apart.