Well, Jin is dead, and Charlie survives. It seems like a good choice at first, as the troubled youth used his remembrance of the island to kick a drug habit and to move from hasbeen rockstar to relevant actor. Unfortunately, once he became famous, he began spreading word of the mysterious island complete with smoke monsters and egyptian statues to the media. They chewed him up and spit him out.

When making a cameo on E!'s The Soup, he was mocked to a point of despair. After the show airs Charlie will take his own life, resulting in a failure of the entire project. You lose.

END (FAIL)