This image was lost some time after publication.

We asked and, like always, you responded en masse to this morning's Blind Item Infidelity Challenge. Apparently when everyone's behaving badly, everyone gets inspired (and creative). After the jump, your purely speculative guesses about naughty rock stars, cheating newlyweds, soulful dykes and skirt-chasing thespians.

Which newly married actor isn t so faithful? Before he walked down the aisle with his lovely actress wife, he walked into a bedroom and got nasty with a hard-partying Hollywood starlet whom many know intimately

You said: Chad Michael Murray, over and over and over again. Murray recently married One Tree Hill co-star Sophia Bush, and you're all certain he delved into the nether regions of either Lindsay Lohan or Paris Hilton (though we're loath to call Paris a starlet or associate her with anything south of the San Fernando valley).

Which diminutive rock star isn t so faithful to his lovely wife? While she keeps the home fires burning, he s out being bad with an exotic woman

You said: Proving that no one can agree on what qualifies as "diminuitive," guesses included Prince, Rob Thomas, Green Day singer Billie Joe, Blink 182's Travis Barker, Gavin Rossdale (is he a star?), Richie Sambora, and last but not least, Ronnie James Dio. So, basically, no one has a clue.

Which skirt-chasing actor has been two-timing not only his wife, but the sexy blond superstar that he s been cheating with? The horndog was spotted making out with a lithe young lovely in front of the Mercer Hotel before checking into a suite for more naughtiness.

You said: Most guessed Johnny Knoxville. Some of you even asserts that the original jackass is staying at the Mercer this week for a SNL gig and "has an aversion to condoms," which would be unfortunate if he were afflicted with some of the nastiness you kids were mentioning (we could never agree, Mr. LawyerMan). According to the laws of the gossip universe, you all have concluded that the blond superstar would be Jessica Simpson, who reportedly became quite close with Knoxville while the two were recently filming the insta-classic Dukes of Hazzard. The lone dissenters guessed Charlie Sheen and Ewan MacGregor as the guilty party.

And the "soulful young pop star" stuck in some lesbian-flavored blackmail...

You're all certain it's Alicia Keys praying to Sappho for support (except for Cap'n Random, who ventured Joss Stone).

As for the "squeaky-clean Hollywood actor" who likes to troll for skanks in the East Village...

Not much chatter from you on this one; only notable guess was Matt Damon. But seriously, who DOESN'T like their East Village girls skanky? Lord knows I don't dare shower before going to sulk outside Hi-Fi. This guy is just doing like the Romans...