This image was lost some time after publication.

In our ongoing study of New York magazine's Look Book feature, in which a completely random New Yorker is interviewed about his or her style, Intern Alexis tackles Ciara Gilmartin, "a young Vivienne Westwood." In order to better understand Ciara's style and the nuances of the Look Book, Alexis interviewed Entertainment Weekly's Timothy Gunatilaka, stand-up comic and filmmaker Katie Halper, and Jim Laakso of Blood Team for some stylish analysis. After the jump, their take on Ciara and her cardigan.

Timothy Gunatilaka - Entertainment Weekly, Attractive Friends

How would you help Ciara - if, that is, you think she needs help - without interfering with her personal style?

I would give her a shopping bag so she doesn't have to wear all the clothes she owns at the same time. She s wearing like twenty-three sweaters right now. But, really, I don t think it s possible anything could interfere or conflict with her style: I want to go to graduate school for global studies and international relations because of the state of the world right now . I love Prada.

Ciara talks about being cheeky at Sarah Lawrence. What sort of "cheeky" things do you imagine she did?

Does cheeky mean you have a second set of cheeks under your eyes? You d think all that Marxist lit she s reading would help her get some sleep. Maybe the sweater-monster punched her in the face?

Ciara got mugged two weeks ago. If you were a mugger, what would you steal from Ciara?

Oh wait, she got mugged? Now I feel bad about making that punching comment... I love Prada.

Ciara didn't really answer the "how do you describe your look?" question. So...how would you describe her look?

By feminine, she means that her clothes are being worn by a female person. And by low maintenance, she means she doesn t open her eyes to dress herself. But when you re wearing three hundred layers, it s hard to match colors. I think Ciara's outfit was actually made from ground up pieces of real clothes. She looks like a librarian for hobos—but in a cute way.

Katie Halper, stand-up comedian/documentary film maker

How would you help Ciara if, that is, you think she needs help without interfering with her personal style?

First, I would help Ciara by reassuring her it's OK, in fact, totally normal, to find Gramsci's Prison Notebooks difficult. He was, after all, writing in code, and I'm not just talking about Italian (I mean to prevent the prison authorities from understanding). I would make sure that she had read Marx or else there's no hope for understanding Gramsci. I can't imagine a global studies/ international relations students could graduate without reading Marx, but these days you just never know, do you?

I would also give Ciara some crime fighting tips. When walking in the concrete jungle that is New York (and not Connecticut):

A) DO NOT, I repeat, DO NOT wear Marc Jacobs, Prada, Anthropologie,
Ted Baker. Even if they are bought at "consignment store[s]" or are presents, I don't care. And, more importantly, neither does the mugger. All we see is the style, which spells muggable for the mugger and danger for Ciara.

B) Whatever you do, do not open your mouth. Nothing reeks of vulnerability more than a "pretty strong" Manchester accent combined with a U.S. liberal arts school affect.

Ciara talks about being cheeky at Sarah Lawrence. What sort of "cheeky" things do you imagine she did?

Although she didn't study IR as an undergraduate, she definitely got some cheeky hands on experience in "international relations." Ciara is not ashamed to admit that she definitely explored her bicurious side while at Sarah Lawrence. She learned the valuable lesson that labels are for jars and realized she didn't believe in anything you can find on a map. Although she claims there were parties where people "go...practically naked" Ciara attended some totally naked parties, although she preferred body painting parties. But now, she prefers Prada.

Ciara got mugged two weeks ago. If you were a mugger, what would you steal from Ciara?

If I were a mugger I would definitely go for the Nars lipstick first because from past mugging experience, I would know how "completely bare" my victim would feel. It would totally violate her. I think that one of the few fundamental truths that everyone in our society agrees on, from the down and out criminal, to the cheeky fashionista, is that a for the modern woman her Scarlet Empress is "the one thing" she "need[s] and love[s]." It's like the timeless question about a tree falling without anyone hearing it. If a woman has her Scarlet Empress stolen, is she still a woman?

Ciara didn't really answer the "how do you describe your look?" question. So how would YOU describe her look?

Contrary to popular belief, Ciara is quite butch and totally high-maintenance.

Jim Laakso, Blood Team

How would you help Ciara if, that is, you think she needs help without interfering with her personal style?

Once I spent a penniless afternoon at a taping of the John McEnroe Show (R.I.P.) on the promise of a free lunch, only to find that the Rice Krispie treats were stale and the Diet Coke was Caffeine-Free. Sidekick John Fugelsang was characteristically charming, but I left hungry and found a rusty thumbtack in my shoe on the way out. Clearly I have no business offering anyone advice on decision-making or daily functioning, especially a girl who wears a nappy librarian's get-up and therefore has her shit at least slightly together. If anything, she should be helping me.

I drank a glass of Bisquick mix for dinner last night while, somewhere, out-of-work funnyman Fugelsang charmed all within earshot. Could Ciara Gilmartin have been among them?

Ciara talks about being cheeky at Sarah Lawrence. What sort of "cheeky" things do you imagine she did?

Fellow Limeys the Cheeky Girls said it in song:

"Ooh boys cheeky girls
Ooh girls cheeky boys
Ooh boys cheeky girls

I never ever ask where do you go
I never ever ask what do you do
I never ever ask what's in your mind
I never ever ask if you'll be mine
Come and smile don't be shy
Touch my bum this is life."

Ciara got mugged two weeks ago. If you were a mugger, what would you steal from Ciara?

Her dignity. And her change purse because I need one.

Ciara didn't really answer the "how do you describe your look?" question. So how would YOU describe her look?

Looks to mine eyes like Belle & Sebastian boinked her with the twee twig. I wear sweaters and ridiculous glasses; we should both be crying together in a corner somewhere.